Best Dairy-Free Heavy Cream Substitute: 4 Alternatives Tested

Finding a good dairy-free heavy cream alternative can be tricky. Not every plant-based cream works the same way, and the best substitute for creamy pasta sauce might not be the best for whipped cream or chocolate ganache.

To help make your selection a little easier, I have tested 4 different dairy-free heavy cream alternatives in three different applications to see how they compare in flavor, texture, performance, and availability.

Whether you are looking for a dairy-free cream for cooking, baking, or whipping, this guide will help you find the best option for your recipe.

What is Heavy Cream and Why Do We Use it?

Traditional heavy cream is made from the high fat layer at the top of unhomogenized milk. In order to meet the FDA standards for heavy cream each carton needs to consist of roughly 36% to 40% milk fat.

Common uses for heavy cream include making whipped cream or icing and adding richness to sauces.

What Dairy-Free Heavy Creams Did I Test?

For this product comparison I tested:

• Califia Farms Dairy-Free Heavy Cream Alternative
• Full-Fat Coconut Milk
• Country Crock’s Homestyle Dairy Free Heavy Whipping Cream
• Silk’s Dairy-Free Heavy Whipping Cream

The Method For Testing Heavy Cream Alternatives

I wanted to see which of these four products worked the best for whipped cream, thick sauces, and dreamy chocolate ganache. For each of these recipes, I followed a specific set of steps to make the testing as fair as possible. Let’s break down each testing method.

Chocolate Ganache

Maintaining consistency was critical to the success of this test. To keep the tests consistent, I followed these rules when making each batch of chocolate ganache to make sure the only difference between the tests were truly the heavy cream alternatives used.

• I used a ratio of 1 to 1 with 4 ounces of heavy cream alternative to 4 ounces of dairy-free chocolate chips.
• The heavy cream alternative was heated between 180°F and 200°F.
• Enjoy life mini chocolate chips were used in each test as the chocolate base.
• The mixture sat 3 minutes before being stirred and cooled for 2 hours at room temperature.
• After cooling 2 hours, I put each sample in the fridge to see if they would set to a scoop-able texture.

Whipped Cream

Just like with the chocolate ganache testing, I wanted to make sure the whipped cream tests were also a fair comparison. For consistency’s sake these were steps I took.

• Whipped 1 cup* heavy cream alternative from chilled.
• Did not add sweetener or flavoring to impact overall volume.
• Mixed in Kitchen-Aid stand mixer, fitted with the whisk attachment, at level 6
• Had a stopwatch to record the time soft, medium, and stiff peaks were reached.
• Poured final whipped cream into a 4 cup measuring cup to get the final volume right away.
• Left final whipped cream in measuring cup for an hour and documented stability in 15 minute intervals.

*For the full-fat coconut milk, I could only get about 1/2 cup of liquid from the can.

Garlic Cream Sauce

One of the main uses for people searching about heavy cream alternatives revolves around how it cooks into a sauce. I took my stripped down garlic cream sauce recipe from the red and white pasta bake and tested each of the heavy cream alternatives to see how it turned out.

• All ingredients besides the heavy cream were the same for each test.
• Each recipe used 1 1/2 cup of dairy-free heavy cream alternative.
• I used Country Crock’s plant butter for the base.
• I let the sauce cool about 5 minutes before tasting.
• The sauce then cooled 15 minutes to see if it would split after cooking.

Overall Points Ranking

I have assigned an overall point value to each of the heavy cream alternatives to help better determine the best overall heavy cream substitute. Points were broken down by:

• Availability: (1 pt easy to get locally, 1/2 point more than 30 minutes away/often out of stock, 0 point difficult to get)
• Taste: (1 point flavor did not impact final dish, 1/2 point flavor was noticeable in the final dish, 0 point flavor overpowered the final dish)
• Ganache: (1 point great, 1/2 point fair, 0 point poor)
• Whipped Cream: (1 point great, 1/2 point fair, 0 point poor)
• Cream Sauce: (1 point great, 1/2 point fair, 0 point poor)

Heavy Cream Alternatives on the Market

There are a number of heavy cream alternatives on the market but for the sake of convenience, I tested the three most popular heavy cream substitutes plus a full-fat coconut milk to see how they work in recipes as a dairy-free alternative to heavy cream. Here is how they whipped up!

Excellent = performed very well; Good = performed well with minor drawbacks; Fair = worked, but had noticeable limitations; Poor = did not perform well in this application.

The hard part about this run of tests is that there was no clear winner for every category. If you are looking to make whipped cream I would suggest the Country Crock. For a sauce, you will be better served with Califia Farms or Full-Fat Coconut Milk.

Califia Farms

Califia Farms is a plant-based heavy cream alternative made primarily from water, coconut oil, sunflower oil, fava bean protein isolate, acacia, xanthan gum, and gellan gum. It claims to be a 1:1 swap for dairy heavy cream and is good for cooking, baking, and dessert.

Get full nutritional information and up to date ingredient information at Califia Farms Dairy-Free Heavy Cream.

Ganache with Califia Farms

• Incorporated: Mixed together smoothly.
• Setting time: 2 hours to thicken, chilled to set.
• Final texture: Smooth and glossy.
• Flavor: Rich chocolate flavor with slight hint of coconut.

Whipped Cream with Califia Farms

I think it is interesting to note that while the manufacturer says it is a 1:1 swap for dairy heavy cream, it does not claim to be for whipping on the packaging but does state whips as a reason to love on their product page.

• How long it took to whip: 1 minute to thicken, 1:30 to fully whip.
• Peak strength: Medium peaks.
• Final volume: Yields 1.5 cups from 1 cup of liquid.
• Stability: Lasted about 30 minutes at room temperature.

Garlic Cream Sauce with Califia Farms

• How it thickened: The cream easily incorporated into the roux and was a little thinner than the sauce normally comes out.
• Did it separate? No separation occurred.
• Taste: Neutral flavor, the garlic was able to come through beautifully.

My Take on Califia Farms Heavy Whipping Cream Alternative

Overall rating: 4.5/5

Califia performed well in all three applications. It earned full points for availability, flavor, ganache, and cream sauce, with a half point for whipped cream because it produced less volume and wasn’t as stable at room temperature as some of the other alternatives.

Best application: Sauce. It quickly incorporated and did not separate when removed from heat. It also didn’t impact the overall flavor of the sauce.

Biggest weakness: Whipping. With 1 cup liquid used to whip and 1.5 cups whipped cream at the end, the result was underwhelming. The whipped cream also doesn’t hold up over time meaning it needs to be used the minute it is made for maximum enjoyment.

Would I buy it again? Yes. If I am planning to make a creamy sauce or chocolate ganache this would be a product I would buy again. I also was able to find it locally and easily at Sprouts Farmers Market which was convenient.

Who should buy it? Califia Farms is a good option if you’re looking for a dairy-free heavy cream alternative for savory sauces or ganache, but I wouldn’t choose it as my first option for homemade whipped cream.

Coconut Milk (Full Fat)

Full-fat coconut milk is often used as a non-dairy alternative for heavy cream due to it’s thick creamy consistency. The Thai Kitchen Organic Unsweetened Coconut Milk is made with organic coconut, water, and organic guar gum. There are no claims about what this product can do as a dairy-free heavy cream alternative.

Note: I used Thai Kitchen Organic Unsweetened Coconut Milk for the ganache and the garlic cream sauce. The coconut milk did not set when chilled 48-hours for the whipping test. For the whipped cream results I used Native Forest Unsweetened Full-Fat coconut milk.

Get full nutritional information and up to date ingredient information at Thai Kitchen Organic Unsweetened Coconut Milk.

Ganache with Full-Fat Coconut Milk

• Incorporated: Easily mixed together with a smooth texture.
• Setting time: 2 hours thickened the ganache, chilled to set overnight.
• Final texture: Slightly grainy with a dull gloss.
• Flavor: Rich chocolate flavor with after taste of coconut.

Whipped Cream with Full-Fat Coconut Milk

The original can of Thai Kitchen coconut milk did not solidify in the refrigerator after 48 hours of chill time. For this test, I switched to Native Forest Unsweetened Coconut Milk.

While Native Forest solidified, there was a layer of coconut oil at the top that needed to be skimmed off before getting to the coconut cream. The results were underwhelming and I decided to try a coconut cream as well. Coconut cream results are included below but not reflected in the overall score for full-fat coconut milk.

• How long it took to whip: 5 Minutes.
• Peak strength: Medium, at best.
• Final volume: 1/2 cup from 1/2 cup of fluid.
• Stability: Holds up for an hour without melting.

*Whipped Cream with Coconut Cream

During my testing, I noticed that the refrigerated coconut cream pulled from the can of coconut milk was a smaller volume, a little grainy, and didn’t add volume.

I stuck to the original brand, Thai Kitchen, for the coconut cream test and chilled the can for 48 hours before testing.

• How long it took to whip: 1 minute
• Peak strength: Stiff peaks
• Final volume: Yields 1 cup of whipped coconut cream for 3/4 cup of coconut cream used.
• Stability: Holds up for an hour without melting.
• Flavor: Strong coconut flavor, borderline soapy.

While a dedicated coconut cream produced better volume and stronger peaks, its pronounced coconut flavor may not work well in every dessert.

These results were not included in the overall scoring, just a bonus to see if concentrated coconut cream worked better than the coconut cream separated from the full fat coconut milk.

Garlic Cream Sauce with Full-Fat Coconut Milk

• How it thickened: Easily incorporated into the roux, had the thickest texture of the sauces.
• Did it separate? No separation occurred.
• Taste: The flavor tasted mildly of coconut but the garlic came through.

My Take on Coconut Milk as a Heavy Cream Alternative

Overall rating: 3/5

Full-Fat Coconut Milk performed well in two applications. It earned full points for availability and sauce. It earned half points for ganache, due to the grainy texture, and taste because it impacts the flavor of other dishes. Zero points earned for whipped cream since the full-fat coconut milk did not whip.

Best application: Sauce. The full-fat coconut milk added a smooth and creamy texture to the sauce and incorporated well.

Biggest weakness: Whipped cream. Having to chill the can up to 48 hours in advance makes it a recipe you need to plan for as opposed to something you can make spur of the moment.

Would I buy it again? Yes. I always keep a few cans of full-fat coconut milk on hand for sauces and soups because it is an addition that adds both flavor and creaminess to a recipe.

Who should buy it? This is the perfect heavy cream for someone on a Paleo or Whole30 diet or anyone simply trying to consume whole foods.

Country Crock Homestyle Dairy-Free Heavy Whipping Cream

Country Crock Homestyle dairy-free heavy whipping cream is a dairy-free alternative to whipped cream made with plant milk, plant based oils, sugar, modified corn starch, sucrose esters of fatty acid, mono- and di-glycerides, salt, guar gum, sunflower lecithin, locust bean gum, and beta-carotene. The package claims that the product will cook, bake, and whip in a 1:1 ratio for replacing traditional dairy cream.

Full nutritional information and up to date ingredient information for can be found here for Country Crock Homestyle Dairy-Free Heavy Whipping Cream.

Ganache with Country Crock Heavy Cream

• Incorporated: Easily mixed into the chocolate.
• Setting time: Noticeably thicker after 30 minutes, chilled in refrigerator overnight to set for a scoop-able finish.
• Final texture: Smooth and glossy.
• Flavor: Rich chocolate flavor.

Whipped Cream with Country Crock Heavy Cream

• How long it took to whip: 1:30 minutes to whip to medium peak.
• Peak strength: Medium peaks.
• Final volume: 3 cups whipped cream for 1 cup liquid whipped.
• Stability: 60 minutes at room temperature with minimal melting or change.

Garlic Cream Sauce with Country Crock Heavy Cream

• How it thickened: Easily incorporated into the roux, took about 5 minutes to fully thicken.
• Did it separate? Yes. The butter and sauce split after the heat turned off.
• Taste: The flavor was neutral and the garlic came through.

My Take on Country Crock Homestyle Dairy-Free Whipping Cream

Overall rating: 4/5

Country Crock performed well in two applications. It earned full points for availability, flavor, ganache, and whipped cream. It earned no points for garlic cream sauce because the final sauce split.

Best application: Whipped cream. Of the four alternatives I tested, this was the best option for making dairy-free whipped cream. It whips 3 times as much as the liquid volume to start and can sit at room temperature for up to an hour without major change.

Biggest weakness: Sauce. The sauce separated, leaving visible pools of butter around the cream sauce. While the flavor was neutral the appearance was off.

Would I buy it again? Yes. This will continue to be my go to product for making whipped cream and subsequently no-churn dairy free ice cream.

Who should buy it? This one is for someone looking to make desserts that rely on a dairy-free whipped cream such as an ice box cake, chocolate eclair dessert, or a no-churn ice cream. I would not recommend this product be used for sauces.

Silk Heavy Whipping Cream

A 16 fluid ounce package of Silk heavy whipping cream alternative is made with water, coconut oil, faba bean protein, guar gum, sunflower lecithin, and natural flavor. The packaging claims the product with whip, cook, and bake with a 1:1 replacement ratio.

Full nutritional information and up to date ingredient information for can be found here for Silk Dairy-Free Heavy Whipping Cream Alternative.

Ganache with Silk Heavy Whipping Cream

• How well it incorporated: Beautifully incorporated into the chocolate.
• Setting time: 1 hour to stick to a spoon, chilled overnight to form to a scoop-able texture.
• Final texture: Smooth and glossy.
• Flavor: Chocolate with slight sweetness and hint of coconut.

Whipped Cream with Silk Heavy Whipping Cream

• How long it took to whip: 20 seconds to start seeing volume, 30 seconds to medium peaks, 1 minute to grainy, separated at 1:30.
• Peak strength: Medium peaks.
• Final volume: 1 cup whipped cream to 1 cup fluid heavy cream alternative used.
• Stability: Some melting at 15 minutes loose and runny at an hour.

I would like to note that the first time I used Silk Heavy Whipping Cream Alternative in 2025 I was able to get the product to whip relatively well. When my first test this time failed, I retested with a second container of Silk heavy whipping cream and got the same results.

I can’t say whether the formulation has changed or whether I received a bad batch. However, my two recent tests produced the same results, and inconsistent whipping performance seems to be an issue other users have experienced as well.

Garlic Cream Sauce with Silk Heavy Whipping Cream

• How it thickened: Melted into the sauce and thickened within 5 minutes.
• Did it separate? No separation occurred in the testing.
• Taste: Kind of sweet, reminded me of coffee creamer and it overpowered the garlic.

My Take on Silk Heavy Whipping Cream

Overall rating: 2.5/5

Silk performed well in two applications. It earned full points for ganache and cream sauce. It earned a half point for taste as it made the garlic cream sauce taste a little sweet. Then, it earned no points for availability as it was out of stock at multiple stores for close to two months and no points for whipped cream since it split, had low volume, and was not stable at room temperature.

Best application: Ganache. The heavy cream worked well in the ganache recipe.

Biggest weakness: Whipping. The liquid used to whip was the same volume of finished whipped cream. It can also quickly become grainy and separate if overwhipped.

Would I buy it again? No. Not only did in not work well in the whipped cream testing it also took away from the flavor of the sauce. Add to it how difficult it was for me to find (over 8 weeks of checking stores that were constantly sold out) and it just isn’t worth the time and money to find it.

Who should buy it? You should buy this if there are no other alternatives available, otherwise you are better served with a different product.

Dairy Free Heavy Cream FAQs

Finding the right dairy-free heavy cream alternative truly depends on what you’re making. For homemade whipped cream, Country Crock was and still is my favorite.

For creamy sauces, I’d reach for Califia Farms or full-fat coconut milk. And if you’re making chocolate ganache, several of these alternatives can get the job done. I hope this testing helps you find the right option for your next dairy-free recipe!

Please let me know in the comments below if there are any dairy-free heavy cream alternatives I may have missed that you absolutely love and would like me to test out!

For more dairy-free recipes and information about a dairy-free lifestyle sign-up for my newsletter below.

First Name

Last Name

I have read and agree to the terms & conditions

Email address:

Leave this field empty if you're human: